25 Mar 2025

Oliver Wyman Masterclass #2: Putting it into practice

In collaboration with the Oliver Wyman Forum and as part of our wider series on transition planning, Chapter Zero members came together for the second of three interactive, practical transition planning masterclasses. These are in-depth learning experiences where attendees learn from both experts and peers. Building from the first masterclass on transition planning foundations and the role of the NED, the second masterclass explored how NEDs can lead through uncertainty, effectively review and challenge transition plans and take into account legal considerations associated with transition planning. This document provides a summary of the rich learnings and key takeaways from the session.

Download the full event summary

You can share the event summary with your fellow board members and colleagues by inviting them to join Chapter Zero, sharing the webpage link with them, and downloading the designed resource here.

Oliver Wyman Masterclass #2: Putting it into practice- Event Summary

Key Takeaways

  1. Connect transition plans with purpose and strategy.
    Effective transition planning should form part of your corporate strategy (even though it is detailed in a separate document), and in alignment with your organisation’s purpose. Transition planning should not be seen as just a moral obligation or compliance exercise; but should be driven by the belief that responding to the climate transition can create significant value for shareholders and enhance sustainability.
  2. NEDs should actively engage throughout the planning cycle.
    NEDs must be proactively involved throughout the transition planning process, asking probing questions to challenge assumptions and drive deeper exploration of critical topics and risks. It is important to have top down alignment and engagement from leadership.
  3. Create credible plans through robust data and clear targets.
    Strong transition plans are underpinned by robust analysis and data, with clear targets and milestones that create accountability and turn a plan from a marketing narrative into a credible plan.
  4. Understand dependencies but don’t let uncertainty be a barrier.
    It is crucial to understand and recognise uncertainties and dependencies on which a transition plan rests, but these should not be used as an excuse or distraction from action.
  5. Treat plans as dynamic documents, using flexible language.
    Transition plans are inherently dynamic documents that require regular review and iteration. Transparency, early communication and use of flexible language can help to mitigate risks of an uncertain future.

Leading through uncertainty

We reinforced our learnings from our first masterclass on the importance of transition planning being integrated into the corporate strategy, as well as the criticality of strong executive leadership and taking a pragmatic approach. We also explored how to lead through uncertainty, with key considerations including:

  • Integrated strategy: Ensure transition planning is embedded in the strategy rather than a sub-strategy
  • Connection with purpose: Cohesion is driven with one goal - ensure there is a clear link between your transition plan and the organisation's overarching purpose
  • Executive leadership as well as holistic organisational engagement is key: We recapped the critical role of the CSO, but that they cannot do it alone and need backing and input from the entire business to succeed
  • Commercial considerations: Work with stakeholders to build transition plans that align with customers and companies wants and needs, ensuring commercial considerations are an input
  • Reality check: Acknowledge uncertainties and interdependencies in transition plans to ensure realistic and actionable strategies
  • Addressing resistance: Form alliances amongst stakeholders and ensure the Chair is engaged. Engage less enthusiastic colleagues through sharing peer case studies to highlight benefits, use probing questions, and leveraging regulatory requirements (whilst avoiding box ticking)

Many organisations are not being swayed by the current uncertain times as they recognise that the climate transition is connected to their core purpose and hence creates an enduring need for transition planning.

-NED Attendee

Effective NED review and challenge of transition plans

We explored how NEDs can effectively review and challenge transition plans, covering some key guiding themes including:

  • The transition planning development cycle is a non-linear iterative process, sometimes spanning 1-2 years; NEDs should be actively engaged at multiple points throughout the entire development, asking probing questions.
  • To take transition planning to the next level, NEDs should challenge their organisations to explore how the topics of Adaptation, Nature and a Just Transition can be incorporated into plans.

Through review and challenge of real-life examples, participants reflected on areas that make a transition plan strong, considering:

What makes for a strong transition plan?

  • Clear targets and milestones to track progress and create accountability
  • Plans need to be underpinned by sufficient data and analysis to ensure credibility
  • Clear sponsorship, ownership and engagement is evident across the whole business
  • The most impactful plans are in line with the sector trends and the company strategy

Where could transition plans go further?

  • Clear baseline and ambition: Many plans outline ambition, but could be improved by clearly outlining the starting point, lessons learned to date and where you expect to go (with a level of realism and understanding of the level of change needed to implement)
  • Compelling narrative and logical flow: Many plans could improve the flow of the narrative, highlighting enablers, interdependencies, and a clear link to the overarching company strategy
  • Embracing innovation: Good plans to embrace innovation, change and flexibility to capture all opportunities

Participants also reflected that, to add value when reviewing and challenging plans, detail, analysis, quality preparation time and carefully curated NED debates are required. To enable this, governance and scrutiny should be applied in the same way as with other technical topics which boards cover.

Participants tackled common debates which often arise within the boardroom when reviewing and challenging transition plans, including how we plan for implicit uncertainty, financial planning detail, how organisations should influence externally, and plans for scope 3 emissions reduction. Through the discussions, participants highlighted several key learnings including:

How should we plan for implicit uncertainty?

It’s important for organisations and boards to understand and plan for uncertainties, but this shouldn't be seen as a barrier to action.

How detailed should transition financial planning be, and over what time horizon?

Transparency over financial planning is important to drive credibility in transition plans. However, it is important to acknowledge uncertainty and outline caveats and assumptions. A useful approach is to give different levels of details over different time horizons to balance credibility with certainty.

What level of action should we be taking to influence externally?

There is a need to identify key dependencies and focus lobbying and external engagement on these. A key way of influencing policy is through disclosure and reporting of dependencies.

How should we be thinking about scope 3 emissions reduction?

Reframing our mindsets on scope 3 away from “a challenging task to reduce our own scope 3” and towards “working with our value chain to help them reduce their scope 1 & 2 emissions”, can make the challenge more manageable and help to drive meaningful progress.

Related Content

Explainer | 24 Mar 2025

Leveraging regulation (part 2): The pathway to resilience and growth

By steering their organisations beyond compliance, NEDs can help harness sustainability reporting as a lever for resilience, innovation, and long-term leadership. Part 2 of this two-part insights piece, from Chapter Zero Fellow David Carlin, explores three key ways that boards can leverage their approach to regulatory changes to gain competitive advantage.

Collaboration with Deloitte Academy
Explainer | 21 Mar 2025

Read: 2025 Sustainability Regulation Outlook

Read this summary from the Chapter Zero and Deloitte Academy webinar, where we explored the Deloitte Academy’s third annual flagship report, focusing on the topics that are considered most critical through the lens of their potential to affect business strategies, operating or financial models for 2025.

Collaboration with Centre for Climate Engagement
Explainer | 19 Mar 2025

UK Climate Policy Briefing - March 2025

Our UK policy briefing aims to highlight the latest developments in UK climate policy directly relevant to NEDs.